The second step in the evaluation process is to answer the questions in the Questionnaire worksheet. If you find the Questionnaire is too wide for your screen, trying hiding the Navigator.
Note: |
For the evaluation results to be complete and reliable, you must provide accurate answers for all of the questions. |
Your response to this question determines the form of the Earnings worksheet. „If you answer Yes, the worksheet will be configured to normalize earnings. „If you answer No, the worksheet will be configured for calculating current Discretionary Income. |
Select the industry that best describes the business you are evaluating. If the business does not belong to any of the industries in the list, choose the first option, None of These Industries Apply. |
Be sure that the annual salary quoted here is not for slave or incompetent labor. A qualified manager will be spending as many hours as the current owner spends, and will have to be paid accordingly. Include all extra costs and benefits in the total. Use the following sources for information: •The owner •Employment agencies •Help Wanted ads |
Use the following guidelines: •Ask the owner and enter that amount. •If the owner or the owner's representatives do not have a specific requirement, enter the estimated market value of the assets. |
Do not exceed original cost when adding salvage value. "Floor planning" is not owned equipment - actually leased. Use the following guidelines: •Consult used equipment dealers for current wholesale prices based on actual physical condition, age and local market demand. •Consult local auctions, trade magazines, etc. •Ask the owner. Caution: This is generally the least accurate source of information. |
Buyers will not pay for used leasehold improvements if they can get a new "build out" for free in a similar space. If you didn't pay for improvements - neither should the buyer. Assuming the current owner paid for leasehold improvements and the local lease market is not providing spaces built to the tenant's specifications, use the following schedules: Long Lived Improvements (10 to 25 year life)Walls, electrical wiring and plumbing can be valued at the original cost of installation with no deduction for depreciation. Inflation rates will compensate for depreciation. Intermediate Lived Improvements (5 to 10 year life)Signs, water heaters, air conditioners, air compressors furnaces, etc. are capital improvements that have a definite lifetime. Use a "straight line" depreciation schedule based on actual useful life. Disposable or fashionable (0 to 5 year life)Carpeting, blinds, draperies, etc. are subject to rapid wear and fashion trend and will be worth: •75% of original cost if in new condition •50% of original cost if in good condition •25% of original cost if in fair condition •0% of original cost if in worn condition |
There are three good sources for vehicle price information: •Blue Book value. This guide is available at many book stores for a nominal fee and is extremely reliable. •Classified ads. Many local publications and newspapers advertise vehicles and the average price from a number of ads will represent the prevailing market price. •Depreciation schedule (minimum value is 20% of original cost) |
Every business has some inventory of stock for internal use or products for resale. The actual value of stocks or inventory is usually determined by a physical inventory completed the day the business sale is consummated. Use the following sources for information: •Have a professional inventory service determine market value. •Use last years tax statement to find your "ending inventory" and "beginning inventory". Be careful: many people make year end adjustments to inventory levels for tax purposes - this question is looking for the value on a "normal day". •Estimation. Ask the owner, purchasing manager or person responsible for stocks. |
This figure will come from conversations with the landlord. |
When researching comparable lease spaces, try to find ones with similar esthetic appeal, road access and exposure. Favorable lease terms are considered an asset and worth money to a buyer. |
When researching comparable lease spaces, try to find ones with similar esthetic appeal, road access and exposure. Favorable lease terms are considered an asset and worth money to a buyer. |
Read the fine print in the lease contract! Lease / purchase agreements are usually not the same as a purchase agreement with installment payments. The fundamental question is - who will get the equity and how much if the item is sold at any time? •If the current owner's terms can be transferred to a new owner at a nominal cost the lease may have an asset value. •If the item can be purchased during or at the end of the lease term this item may have an asset value. •If the item has no ownership available there is no asset value! |
If the right cannot be transferred legally - there is no asset value! If replacement or residual value cannot be determined because this item is a product of creativity and therefore unique - do not attempt to place a value without professional research assistance! Use the following guidelines to determine license or permit worth: Similar Permits AvailableIf similar permits are currently available and these permits have no expiration date, start with the current replacement cost and add acquisition costs. If similar permits are currently available and these permits have a definite expiration date use these formulas to calculate residual value: •Value Per Month = Permit Fee ÷ Permit Duration in Months •Consumed Value = Value Per Month × Months Since Permit Issued •Residual Value = Permit Fee – Consumed Value Information/DatabasesInformation or databases are generally valued by: •What was the original cost to create it? •What would it cost to replace today? •Where else is this data available at what cost? •What percent of revenue uses this data directly? •What percent of data is annually obsolete? OtherLicenses, patents, unique permits, dealerships, copyrights, and similar legal rights are valued by security and income generation. Price can be determined by the following methods: •Ask the seller what they will take to release all and part of currently held rights. •Research the local market for recently sold permits or rights and use the trend of prices •Find two (2) or three (3) direct competitors and ask what they would take to sell all and part. |
Use the last 12 months - not the last fiscal year! Do not include unusual income or income from sources that are not included in this sale! |
Obtain a copy of the most recent tax return or financial statement. Usually extraneous income is listed as "other income" or "sale of assets". Do not include this income! Be sure that the revenue reported was actually generated by the business being sold. Buyers and the IRS do not accept two sets of books. |
Obtain a copy of a tax return or financial statement from one (1) fiscal year prior to the last. Usually extraneous income is listed as "other income" or "sale of assets". Do not include this income. Be sure that the revenue reported was actually generated by the business being sold. Buyers and the IRS do not accept two sets of books, and don't trust what "second sets of books" read. If its not absolutely legal don't use it! |
Some sources for this information: •The owner •The company marketing manager •The company sales manager •A purchasing agent from a client company •Secretary of State •Chamber of Commerce |
Go down this list until the criteria describes this business. Do not quote sale or special low rates. •The business shows consistent growth over many years, with no management required, and is in a proven and very stable industry: use the highest interest rate on local credit cards. •The business shows growth almost every year, with little management required, and is in a proven and very stable industry: double the current interest rate for a fixed rate 30 year conventional mortgage. •The business shows profits, is in a good industry and requires management; however, it hasn't been established very long: double the current interest rate for vehicle loans through a financial institution. •The business is not consistently profitable, requires extensive management or is not proven over time: double the highest interest rate on local credit cards. •The business has been unprofitable, the owner controls all functions and isn't established: triple the highest interest rate on local credit cards. |
The best source for this information is a "Venture Capitalist". Venture capitalists invest in businesses that lending institutions will not consider. Venture capitalists expected annual rates of return usually range from 35% to 75%. For an estimate, add 10% to the rate of return you chose in the previous question, and each time the business meets a criteria in the list below, add another 10%. •The business is less than five (5) years old. •You can count the exact number of clients. •The seller wants all cash when sold. •Profits are not consistent. •Owner is operator. |
Use the following schedule of criteria to determine your answer. You must meet all the criteria in the next level to use that value. 75%•Basically verbal information •Some Documents 80%•Some financial data is available •Some outside research was done •The owner gave verbal values •Tax statements were done by a CPA 85%•Some financial data is from statements •Some outside research was done •The physical inventory values are not clearly documented •A CPA prepares this company's statements 90%•All financial data is from statements •Most outside research is documented •The physical inventory is represented by some documents •A CPA prepares this company's statements 95%•All financial data is from audited statements •All outside research documents are enclosed •A physical inventory has been completed •Routine statements are generated by a CPA |
Call a banker. Knowing a banker by name may be valuable in the future. The term "professional" refers to complete information and no fraudulent data! |
Do not read anything into this question or assume it means equivalents to cash. |
Try one or more of these methods: •Divide the estimated value of assets by the total estimated annual costs. •Divide maintenance expenses by the book value of all assets. •Ask the owner or manager. |
Divide owner's suggested down payment by owner's suggested price. If the owner or owner's representative do not have a specific figure in mind, use 100%. |
Call a local banker. |
"Dead stock" can be defined as: •Broken lots of goods in a retail store •Disorganized storage of materials •Obsolete parts or merchandise Normal Bad Stock LevelsNormal bad stock levels will range from 5% in a very well run organization to as much as 40% in a poorly managed shop. Listed below are suggested sources of information: •Consult trade associations for averages •If suppliers stock the shelves (mainly retail shops) ask them for suggestions. •Compare "inventory turns" for this company versus Robert Morris or similar standards. •Talk to the employees that work with the merchandise daily to see how the company tracks and handles old stock. •Visually inspect supplies and stocks for age, dust, and application. •Ask the owner Types of Companies with High Bad Stock LevelsThe quantity of useless stock is highest in four types of companies: •New businesses with less than 5 years experience. •Older businesses that do not have set policies regarding purchasing and utilization. •Companies that do not have a specific person controlling inventory levels. •Companies losing money, particularly if it is a retail business. •When suppliers do not allow the return of merchandise. •When the owner can't remember the last time the stock room was thoroughly cleaned of old stock. |
Use total number of full time employees and part time employees. Family members do not count in seniority group! |
The inflation index has many categories. Choose the category that applies to the majority of your expenses. Listed below are some of the categories: •Wholesale Price Index Inflation index information can be obtained from the following sources: •Public Library •Chamber of Commerce •Almanac |
What percent of down payment does the seller "philosophically" expect? Add any notes or credit lines that the seller will co-sign or "wrap" promissory notes that do not require or consume the buyer's own credit. •Enter value of transferable credit or note •Enter owner's price or asset value •Total transferable credit plus owner financing |
Ask the owner. Fixed rate loans are generally desirable over variable rates because of stability in planning. Variable rate loans generally indicate a very uncertain economic future. |
Ask the owner. If the owner will not finance the sale or is using a variable rate enter the current bank rate for annual interest vehicle loans or long term fixed mortgages. |
Ask the owner. |
Start with 100%. Deduct owner's suggested down payment percent. Deduct the percent of owner financing. |
Ask your local banker what type of interest rate most businesses are currently applying for. You might also consult the Small Business Administration or similar agencies. Any loan must be based on this business's assets alone and not the assets of the buyer. |
Ask your local banker what interest rate most businesses at this scale are currently receiving. You might also consult the Small Business Administration or Economic Development Council. Any loan must be based on this business's assets alone and not the assets of the buyer. |
Ask your local banker what interest rate most businesses at this scale are currently receiving. You might also consult the Small Business Administration or Economic Development Council. Any loan must be based on this business's assets alone and not the assets of the buyer. |
Ask your banker. Check the newspapers. Search the Internet. |
Ask the owner. |
Include the following: •Owner if they work routinely •All actively working partners •All working family members of owner •All working family members of partners |
Follow these rules: •Generally a retail business sells to so many people that a exact number of clients cannot be determined. Just make a reasonable estimate. •A wholesale, contracting, processing, or manufacturing business often has a finite number of accounts. Try to get an exact count. •If one account has independent purchasing groups, and disqualification from one purchasing group does not disqualify the company from all purchasing groups, then count each purchasing group as a separate account. |
To calculate the revenue amount: •Start with gross revenue for past 12 months. •Deduct any extraneous revenue. •Divide the result by four (4) What is the least number of accounts that is required to equal this 25% of gross revenue? •Sort the company's accounts in descending order by the volume of business transacted over the past 12 months. •When sorting accounts, consider that some large companies have regions and divisions that purchase independently. These individual regions, if they act autonomously in choosing clients, can be counted as individual accounts. |
Read the actual lease! Do not count a lease option if the rent or service charges can be escalated without limitations! |
The months or years allowed for repayment of a loan are usually related to the average life of the assets unless the firm has been established for a long time. Listed below are some guidelines: •Ask your banker. •The depreciation schedules issued by the IRS allow for various periods of time to write off assets. Use these guidelines for maximums and minimums based on the types of assets in this company. •Ask the owner what terms seem reasonable. By business type: •New small retail or service business: 1-3 years •Small retail or service businesses: 2-5 years •Medium retail or service businesses: 3-6 years •Small size, short lived heavy assets: 3-7 years •Small size, medium assets, established: 5-7 years •Medium size, heavy assets long lived: 7-10 years •Large size, heavy assets long lived: +10 years |
The months or years allowed for repayment of a loan are usually related to the average life of the assets unless the firm has been established for a long time. Listed below are some guidelines: •Ask your banker. •The depreciation schedules issued by the IRS allow for various periods of time to write off assets. Use these guidelines for maximums and minimums based on the types of assets in this company. •Ask the owner what terms seem reasonable. By business type: •New small retail or service business: 1-3 years •Small retail or service businesses: 2-5 years •Medium retail or service businesses: 3-6 years •Small size, short lived heavy assets: 3-7 years •Small size, medium assets, established: 5-7 years •Medium size, heavy assets long lived: 7-10 years •Large size, heavy assets long lived: +10 years |
You can: •Ask the owner •Visually inspect the inventory for maintenance and care to see if aging is happening faster or slower than projected by depreciation schedules and expected asset lives. •Use sampling techniques. Pick a major category of stock or equipment, calculate the various ages and average those ages. |
"Functionally" means the ability to maintain the current level of activity with modest growth and handling all routine problems. Your answer represents intensive training time. Consult the owner and some direct competitors. Assume this individual is above average in financial ability, intelligence and management skills. |
The main purpose of this question is to determine how easily competitors can get into this business's market and compete directly. A good way to approach this question is to assume all brand new equipment set on the shortest depreciation schedules available, a small amount of trained employees and some customers already available. If you filed a tax statement each month, without using tax loopholes or extraneous credits, how many months would pass before you had to pay taxes? A second approach would consider cash flow. Be sure to deduct a salary for the owner or manager. How long would it take for the cash flow to cover the debt service on new equipment, general expenses, billing lags etc. If bonding or special permits are transferable and required to do all types of this company's work, the time lag of obtaining such credentials would be additional. |
In addition to paid full time employees, include all family and partners who work in this business full time, paid or unpaid. |
In addition to paid part time employees, include all family and partners who work in this business part time, paid or unpaid. |
Do not include any paid time or management contracts. |
This question is directed at the cost of collections and the residual value of goods or services if repossessed. Open Account No SecurityAccounts receivables customers that purchase or receive good or services and use or distribute the product in such a way that repossession is virtually impossible. Light SecurityThese accounts are similar to the first category but your product or service can be repossessed easily. Moderate SecurityAccounts receivables are backed by lien or attachment laws that assist in collections. In some states a lien can be filed against the title or deed to property thereby requiring payment at the time of sale of the property. Checks and charge cards do not insure collection, therefore, a loss of some level is generally incurred. Heavy SecurityAccounts receivables are with extremely stable or reliable customers. Collection is generally assured and such receivables can be collateralized instead of factored. Cash Only at Point of SaleCash and cash only! |
NoneNo competitors in trade area and operations show a profit. A FewThere are a few competitors but work and customers are plentiful. SomeEmployees have to hustle and work to make operations profitable because competitors are around every corner. A Fair AmountPrices are falling, costs are still rising, a couple good operations have closed and profits are slimming fast. Many or Next DoorNobody in this trade area is making any money and a few good operators have laid off people or closed. |
More than once a dayOwner calls several times every day. DailyOwner calls every day, but usually only once. Weekly or a few times per weekOwner calls once to several times each week. May schedule when he will call in advance. OccasionallyOwner calls to discuss the business, but only infrequently. Never or no calls related to the businessIf the owner calls, it is only to discuss non-business matters. These calls typically include an account of what a great time he is having. |
The selections in the list should be self-explanatory. Select the typical method used to hire the last few employees. |
The selections in the list should be self-explanatory. Select the option that best describes the training required. |
NoneThere is nothing mechanical, sharp or heavy in the work place. SlightThis work requires some light lifting, most sharp objects are protected or manually operated and there are no hazardous products. Directly Responsible for SafetySome safety training and good common sense is required to prevent injuries. SevereMinor injuries are almost daily with major injuries periodically. Hazardous or Life ThreateningSafety in this work place requires formal training and fatalities or long term health problems occur in this industry. |
IndispensableThe owner is the business. Very ImportantThe owner controls all activities. Moderately ImportantThe owner makes all major decisions. Somewhat ImportantThe owner shows up periodically. Not Important (Absentee)No one is sure who the owner is. |
Severe DeclineRevenues have dropped off sharply. DeclineRevenues have dropped off somewhat. No ChangeRevenues are essentially flat. GrowthSlight but definite growth after discounting inflation. Strong GrowthGrowth beyond local or national inflation rates. |
Owner is essential to all new businessThe owner is the sales force. Employees are not involved in obtaining new business and don't make sales decisions. Owner is involved in most new businessThe owner is a member of the sale force. He contacts clients and solves their problems, in most cases directly. Owner is moderately involvedMost contact is through employees who can make significant decisions. The owner steps in when a serious problem arises. Owner is sometimes involvedCustomers deal with sales representatives in all cases. The owner may be consulted but is never in direct contact with customers. Owner has no involvementAll sales are handled by employees. The owner has no involvement in obtaining new business. |
The best sources of information on this question are bankers and business brokers. Ask some local bankers if any loans are currently being made for this type of business. Ask some local business brokers how this type of business is currently selling. Be sure to consult more than one source for this information. To qualify a business for the next higher level, all criteria in the current level must be met. Three out of four criteria does not count. Undesirable•Many hours of work are required with some profit. •Very few loans are being made on this type of assets. •Even at a low price, demand is limited. •Documents of costs and revenues aren't available. Less Than Average•A good business with profits and some professional standing. •The banker will discuss a loan but is discouraging from the beginning. •The business broker is somewhat encouraging. •Some documents of costs and revenues are available. Average•A business with a consistently good profit margin. •The banker will discuss a loan and is marginally hopeful. •The business broker is encouraging. •Good documents of costs and revenues are available More Than Average•This business has been profitable and is well organized. •The banker is fairly encouraging. •The business broker is positive of a sale. •Financial statements are complete and clear. Highly Desirable•Protected from competition by legal restrictions. •Guaranteed or very secure profits. •Requires little or no time from the owner. •The banker is talking terms. •The business broker is absolutely positive of a sale. •Audited financial statements. |
No Confidence (Wild Guess)Roll the dice" or the business is too new to know. Little Confidence (Mostly Guesswork)After about 6 months into the year we'll have an idea of the trends. Somewhat ConfidentThis company knows its cost and controls them but information about future trends is very difficult to obtain for planning purposes. Moderately ConfidentThis company budgets funds but tends to miss economic trends in spite of forecasting and previous years trend analysis. Highly ConfidentThis company budgets funds and is fairly accurate. |
These answers apply to both the business and the industry: DownRates have been reduced. UnchangedRates are the same if discounted for inflation. Up SomewhatRates are up above reasonable inflation. Up SharplyOur insurance carriers use government pools and special rate adjustment plans to compensate for losses, but a couple carriers are available. Almost Impossible to Get InsuranceThis company takes insurance if offered by a carrier or is in a government pool. |
Answer should represent activity over the past three years in this company's trading area. |
A good key for understanding the true age of an industry is to look at trade magazines and associations. Use the age of these as a guide. |
Do not exaggerate or wish! Read local newspapers and listen to competitors. |
Do not exaggerate or wish! Read national newspapers and listen to competitors. |
Consider these factors: •Retail businesses must have slow to moderate speed traffic to be good. •Industrial businesses must be close to shipping and receiving routes. •Vehicle intense businesses must be centrally located to their service area. •Compare local competitors locations to this one. •Is the labor you want available in this area ? |
Highly CompetitiveNew employees must be paid a premium or moved in from out of the area. NormalWages seem about right or a little high but good people are available. Little Competition (Unemployment)Talk is around about available people or applications are flowing in without request. |
SimpleService businesses that tend to use products and labor to generate revenue. Capital equipment is usually minimal. LightRetail businesses that generate revenue by selling a product without processing it to the general public. IntermediateLight manufacturer, contractor, processor etc. where revenues are generated in larger increments and the physical plant consists of a fleet of vehicles and other capital equipment. These businesses mainly serve other businesses with a service or products. They generally do not deal on a retail level. ComplexHeavily capitalized with massive plant facilities. Generally sell to distributors or wholesalers. |
No Union PresenceNo unions in the business's crafts in this area. All Competitors Non-UnionSome crafts are unionized but they have not organized employees at this business or at its competitors. Some Competitors UnionizedSome of the business's competitors are unionized. All Competitors UnionizedAll of the business's competitors are unionized. The union is trying to organize the business's employees. Business is UnionizedThe business is unionized. |